17 July 2007

Boxing Metaphors Are So 19th Century, I'm In the OCTAGON, Baby . . .

How to Win a Fight With a Conservative is the ultimate survival guide for political arguments

My Liberal Identity:

You are an Eco-Avenger, also known as an environmentalist or tree hugger. You believe in saving the planet from the clutches of air-fouling, oil-drilling, earth-raping conservative fossil fools.



I was cited as a "green journalist" before, so I guess this makes sense.

How to Win a Fight With a Liberal is the ultimate survival guide for political arguments

My Conservative Identity:

You are a Freedom Crusader, also known as a neoconservative. You believe in taking the fight directly to the enemy, whether it’s terrorists abroad or the liberal terrorist appeasers at home who give them aid and comfort.



And that's just silly, I'm much more of a paleo-conservative than a neo-con.

Nuance isn't the strong suit of internet quizzes.

(hat tip RIA and Cal at Done With Mirrors)

UPDATE:

Reader I Am responds in the comments (read it for yourself) and here's a partial response to her response:

The OCTAGON reference is to Mixed Martial Arts which is the newer, shinier, and growing in popularity version of man on man violence as spectacle.

"Duking it out" is an appropriate metaphor for politics, but Marquess of Queensburry rules are the 19th century part, in the 21st century we're seeing a return to valuing combatants who are capable of multiple modes of kicking another guy's (or gal's) ass (grappling, boxing, kickboxing).

Politics aren't by Queensburry rules, either, the politicians and political movements that thrive in the United States over the next few decades will be the ones that are willing to challenge the rules, skirt the rules without getting caught, and push the rules as far as they'll go while still being appealing to the spectators (like a good MMA combatant).

I think the MMA days of politics will be better, once everyone adjusts to the shift. More contact between the participants, will lead to more sharply defined positions during the campaigns, hopefully. With all the mud that will get slung, I think a return to ideas is inevitable. When every potential politician has a hard drive full of pictures of drunken high school and college bacchanals, they'll have no choice but to compete on ideas instead of which candidate is 'more pure'.

1 comment:

reader_iam said...

Yes, but you're so hip, you're hip to the un-hip--that is, the boxing metaphor.***

Damn, baby--You Are What You Are!

(And I thank God for it.)

----

***I dunno. It strikes me that the "duking it out" metaphor is both universal and transcendent, at least for the likes who resemble the likes of me. At least sometimes.

Only sayin'.